I play against him yesterday Melo is a great player ailleurd, it does not hack on our server, only the fact his brother unfortunately, it's true that this will be complicated as it has the same IP but you have my word, the word of a clan admin DN if it please you unban the player. I spec many times last night when I play against him, this player is clean

Well, from the word of a clan leader:
Too bad for him that his brother have cheated on other servers. The fact is that IF we unban that IP that both of these players use, we WOULD have to LET a CHEATER play on the server as well, and that is NOT something I would want to do.

Unless Jonny says otherwise he stays BANNED. And I pretty sure Jonny wants his server clean from cheaters as well.

I'm not even an admin, so i know i dont have really much to say in this case... but im gonna give you some reading so so


from the view of a guy who in SWAT4 game spent 3 years to catch (get a clear proof) of one of clan leaders hacking:

EVEN IF we say that his "my brother" story is real, than as Shaya said, we would have to let both them play in our server, which gives us the risk that we just give a statement "hey lovly cheater, feel free to visit our server". I guess that noone wants it.

So even if we say that the "my brother" story is real (which in my honest opinion IS real), than i understand, that a clean player gets also banned because of some hacker... But so so i prefer them both banned, than letting a cheater in, thats the 1st thing
and the 2nd thing is that here - by keeping their IP banned - we get exacly the same effect as range bans do. Not an old example: loosrshunter - his range IP got banned, and therefore also some clean and good behaving players might also not be able to visit the server... but so so rangeban was kept. (P.S. Loosershunter of course is not a hacker, so it is not a rly simmilar case, but i used this just as an example)

So shortly saying:
1. clean huy let in, hacker let in
2. clean guy not let in, hacker not let in
I choose the 2nd option... A lesser evil


EDIT:
for some reasons which will be understood probably by ImNoob only i didnt correct it, it add it here:
in the 1st option "huy", i ment of course "guy"

Okay, I just realized something when I had a look in the ban list.
The ban occurred 1 hour before I banned Melo.

Melo's brother did cheat on our server. Thanks An!
"Hasn't hacked for a long time".. Right..

---

25/01/2012 14:00:52
low_gravity[MTX]
89.92.198.28
Aimbot, Wallhack
http://www.2shared.com/file/aKwIwAqL/2012_1_25_14_15_8_low_gravityM.html
An-2[pl]
Perm

thats like the oldest trick in the world ... "i didnt cheat, it was my 90 year old grandma, she must have rolled over to my computer in her wheelchair when i was in church praying for a better world"

or the story with yourmumsbutt

"i was in the bathroom and my friend installed the aimbot"

all bullshit

"i was downloading mom-porn and it actually was self-installing mombot, it tricked me"